1. Home
  2. Politics
  3. National
  4. Post SC poser, BJP justifies stand

Post SC poser, BJP justifies stand on LoP

PTI 22 Aug 2014, 23:47:39 PM IST
New Delhi: With the Supreme Court asking the government to make its stand clear on the Leader of Opposition issue, BJP today sought to justify the denial of the post to Congress citing precedents and insisted that the matter was ultimately under the purview of the legislature.  

Referring to previous seven times when there was no Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, BJP said it is the job of the legislature to decide on the issue and the matter was in the Speaker's domain, who had taken the right decision.  

“In matters of legislature, Parliament is supreme and it has to do its work as per rules and traditions. Parliament, which lays rules and procedure, only will decide on Leader of Opposition. We respect the judiciary, but it is still the job of the legislature to decide on the issue,” BJP spokesperson Shahnawaz Hussain said.

The Speaker is the chief of the people's representatives and has decided on the issue as per rules and precedents, he said. “Congress was following wrong traditions and when the right tradition is being followed it is raising a hue and cry,” he said, attacking the opposition party.  

“In a democracy, people of the country decide who will rule and who will be in the opposition. As per the Constitution, the democracy is for the people and by the people.

“People have decided that Narendra Modi will be the leader of the country while they considered Congress as not deserving even to hold the Leader of Opposition's post. This is not the first time it has happened. Then why such ‘hangama' (hue and cry),” he said.

“Parliament is the soul of any democracy. In a representative form of democracy, can anybody change that collective wisdom of people. If people of India have given a verdict, the country has to respect that.  “The country has seen precedents. Seven times there have been no Leader of opposition. You ought to have the right to get that post,” said Meenakshi Lekhi, another BJP spokesperson.

Another BJP spokesperson, Nalin Kohli, said Congress must introspect as to why the people have not given it the numbers required to get the Leader of Opposition post and that it cannot be given to them on the basis of “politics of entitlement”.

“...this cannot be given on the basis of politics of entitlement. Whatever happens will be on basis of rules, tradition and constitutional position,” he said.  Lekhi also sought to question why Congress did not give the Leader of Opposition status to others the previous seven times when it was in power.

She said in the matter of selection of statutory bodies when there is no recognised LoP, the government will maintain transparency by evolving a system by either including the leader of the largest party in Lok Sabha or by other means.

Meanwhile, Home Minister Rajnath Singh asked Congress to honour the decision of the Speaker not to grant the status of Leader of Opposition to it in the Lok Sabha.  

“As per the Constitution, a party must get 10 per cent seat (for Leader of Opposition status). But unfortunately it did not happen. So, they should accept it,” Singh said.  

The reaction came in the wake of Supreme Court deciding to go into the issue of interpreting the provision of Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha in the matter of selection of statutory bodies when there is no recognised LoP and asked the government to make its stand clear on the issue within two weeks.

A bench, headed by Chief Justice R M Lodha emphasised the importance of the post saying Leader of Opposition conveys the voice of representation different from government in the House and is an important component (under Lokpal law) and the issue needs objective consideration in view of current political dispensation when there is no Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha.